The Bone Garden
Tess Gerritsen
Fiction; Mystery (historical)
This excellent stand-alone historical mystery is my first read of Gerritsen’s, and I was not disappointed. In the present, recent divorcee Julia Hamill has bought an old house and to her dismay, discovered an unmarked grave on the property. The fractured bones of an unknown young woman take us into the past, to the early 1800’s, when the rapidly growing field of medical study was just beginning to flourish in the U.S., particularly on the east coast.
A penniless Irish peasant with nothing but the clothes on her back and her dead sister’s newborn baby is relentlessly pursued by shadow figures through the back streets of Boston, and a vicious, Jack-the-Ripper type serial slasher is terrorizing the city. Medical student Norris Marshall is reluctantly drawn into a mystery that he soon realizes is far more sinister than he ever imagined, and for he and Rose to save themselves they must stay one step ahead of those who will do literally anything to keep a deadly secret.
What makes this story so rich and unique is the vivid historical depiction of that early time in modern medicine, from primitive infection control and grave-robbing to provide cadavers for medical students to study, to poet Oliver Wendell Holmes’ own significant role in the medical field at that time (he’s featured in the story as a fellow student and friend to Norris). I felt fully as if I were seeing 19th-century Boston through the eyes of Rose and Norris. It is definitely reminiscent of the “From Hell” Ripper story, which I’m sure served as at least partial inspiration, with the setting moved to the U.S. and featuring American historical figures. That doesn’t make it any less a terrific story! Unfortunately and for reasons I cannot fathom, the two literary reviews on Amazon – one from Publishers Weekly, the other from Booklist - were not favorable. I’m going to have to part company with both of them, though, and say that I thought it was excellent and recommend it to any fan of the mystery/suspense genre, particularly historical suspense.